One of the top performing employees I worked with during my time in HR was constantly late. They generally managed to get their shit together for big important meetings but otherwise was very rarely on time to work or any of their less important obligations.
I wondered how they got to skate on being late to everything until I found out that this person was great at their job and was usually late because they were doing something that was above and beyond (yet very necessary).
This wasn’t an issue until a year later when an employee we were placing on a PIP for, among other things, being late brought it up. Why was this an issue only for them, they wondered?
That lack of consistent application came rushing back as I read some new research on this from GCheck called, rightfully so, The Performance Privilege.
It found that around half of managers backed a policy exception for a top performer versus just above a quarter for the typical one. More than 80% of managers say that their policies should apply equally but nearly 60% say that top performers get more leniency.
If that seems unfair, you’re right. If that seems like human nature, you’re also right.
Everyone seemed willing to forgive the actions of someone who routinely overdelivered, even if their actions were unprofessional and often wasted valuable time. They were more hesitant when those same actions came from someone with a less stellar track record of success.
Where does AI fit in?
New research from Mercor shows that frontier models regularly miss risk in routine enterprise work when those risks aren’t explicitly laid out. These are the types of tasks that I hear about getting handed to models. In one example, a frontier model deleted a file that should’ve been preserved under legal discovery. Even though it had the context of the task (including a document that mentioned what types of files should be preserved), the risks and boundaries were not explicitly stated when assigning the task.
AI is great at a ton of tasks. When given proper instructions, context and model selection, it can go faster, see blind spots, and be more consistent than a human can ever hope. In short, it is a high performer in many of its most critical outputs.
But it also doesn’t always behave.
I don’t anthropomorphize AI the way some folks do but it is clear that we must acknowledge the human nature of looking past defects in these tools when they are otherwise providing value. And for vendors, it’s critical to think about what controls you have in place that make risks explicit if you are depending on their models for answers.
Good luck?
What else is happening this week
I Have a New Website, and It’s Built Like It’s 2006. Laurie Ruettimann launched a blog-first site she owns outright and brought back the blogroll, with me at number one. I love the new site (and a reminder to fix mine).
We Must Act Our Wage. With AI taking over transactional recruiter tasks, John Vlastelica asks whether recruiters create enough value to justify their pay. I love a good play on words.
Employer’s Holiday Guide. Every good holiday party story is usually a bad one for HR, and Heather Bussing offers legal and practical suggestions for the holidays at work.
My New Resource Sheet on Modernizing Job Posts. Kat Kibben shares the resource sheet from their HRCI webinar, which has job search data, template picks and four changes that take little effort. Good resource here.
The Recruiter Is Dead. Long Live the Talent Strategist. Brian Fink gives the recruiter’s job about five years and says closing is all that survives once AI takes sourcing, screening and coordinating. Great insights from the tip of the recruiting change spear.
The Real ROI of AI Depends on Your People. Dan Schawbel walks through a Workplace Intelligence and Deloitte survey where 61% of change management leaders say AI is moving faster than employees can handle. Lots of people are still lost in the woods but not everyone.
How HR Can Prepare for Jobs That Don’t Yet Exist. Series 58 highlights from David Green’s Digital HR Leaders podcast include Jack Buckley of Roblox, Mike Wynn of Bank of America and Himanshu Palsule of Cornerstone. Another great issue from him.
Saving Family Legends if Time Is Running Out. George Anders talks with Luke Palder of MemoirGhostwriting.com about finishing a family memoir when the author is too frail. Love this and its application to telling stories is spot on.
The Quiet Sociology of the Office Potluck. The office potluck is a workplace Rorschach test, says Robin Schooling. I haven’t done an office potluck in so long and for this, I am glad.
Have You Tried Turning It Off and On Again? Single points of failure were a theme of the week for Steve Smith, with Outlook down for nearly a day in more than 70 countries. Resilience is hard.
What the Replies to My HR Tech Thesis Are Telling Us. George LaRocque sorts the pushback to his post-HR Tech LinkedIn posts into three threads: consolidation, who owns the agent and whether candidates will maintain another profile. I like when someone other than me tells him he’s wrong.
A Cautionary Tale of Going Too Fast and Forgetting the Foundations. Nicholas W.J. Biron links Microsoft, the FAA and Workday and says speed and faster tools create vulnerabilities. And more happening this week.
Someone Is Hiring in Our Name. It Isn’t Us. Scammers use Humareso’s name for fake jobs, and Jamie Aquila describes a Texas woman who got a check by FedEx and letterhead telling her to buy equipment. It’s going to be tough sledding out there, especially for third-party recruiters.
Your Next Door Opens Through Someone You Barely Know. At Catalyst by Beemok in Charleston, Ben Navarro raised weak ties, and Jason Averbook writes that what comes next often arrives through someone you barely know. Good ideas here and I’ve always thought those loose connections were underrated.
Sufficient and Justified. Maria Colacurcio writes about her daughter’s test that pay must feel sufficient to survive and justified. Strong piece here.
Name the Last Thing Your Team Stopped Doing. A team cheers an AI dashboard built in two days but only nods at a retired weekly report, and Rui Bashir says taking work away is harder. If the only way a person can get ahead is by doing something new, that’s what they will do.
Black Swan. Kristy McCann sets Sequoia’s March 2020 memo beside 2026 and a week that includes the FAA grounding all planes three days after an AI tool launched. So much going on here.
Don’t Be a Butt-Waffle! Jason Seiden’s 32nd birthday letter to his daughter recalls her answer at ten to a leadership dilemma, that the only way to win is not to play. This isn’t a work story but it actually is.
Two Themes From Episode 62. Meg Bear says she and Amy Wilson keep seeing two themes after a conversation with Master Burnett of HireBrain, outcomes over hierarchy and authenticity so the right people opt in. I am seeing these two.
Story Effect: Off the Record. Another good newsletter here. Matt Tatum recommends colleague Danielle Krischik’s new monthly newsletter, a mix of stories and “cheat codes” for leading like a human.
A Thursday Discussion on the Latest AI News. Mike Wood is talking about the latest AI news Thursday with Mark Vickers and says he’ll try to disrupt the conversation with outrageous conspiracies. Don’t miss this.
I Lied on a Podcast. Vadim Liberman named resilience on a caregiving podcast, but says after eight years of caring for his mother he is weaker, not more resilient. A must listen podcast as caregiving is back in the spotlight thanks to a skit on SNL.
It’s Time to Talk More About This ‘Janky’ Job Market. Six weeks after being laid off, Wendy Dailey has had two phone screens from dozens of applications and starts assembling doors after Thanksgiving. This market is completely baffling.
Positioning Is Everywhere and People Still Can’t Tell the Vendors Apart. Jonathan Goodman says the HR Tech recaps reopened his conclusion that positioning had been commoditized, and cites my thumb-over-the-logo test. This is good.
Status: Retiring From Full Time. After wrapping up his time as Global VP of Strategic Initiatives at Cornerstone, Mike Bollinger is leaving room for work that interests him. Happy trails to him, one of my favorite clients and projects I’ve worked on.
In the news
What the Midterms Mean for AI in HR: ‘Don’t Wait for Washington to Get Tidy’ via HR Executive
Job Applicants Say They Are Using AI to Discover, Investigate Companies via HR Dive
Analysts Sped Up With AI, but Also Followed Its Lead via Reworked
Deloitte: AI Is Reshaping Work Faster Than Orgs Are Changing Authority via HR Executive
Some Employers Are Recruiting Workers They Laid Off for AI via HR Brew
Chief AI Officers Lack Control Over AI Spending: Study via HCA Magazine
Why Microsoft Is Aiming to Make Copilot the ‘OS for Work’ via GeekWire
How AI Is Changing the Way Employees Spend Time at Work via Gallup
Workday Adds Bersin’s Galileo AI Agent to Sana via Reworked
AI May Not Be an Attorney, but Your Employees Use It as if It Were via HR Daily Advisor
US Department of Labor Issues Opinion Letters Addressing Fair Labor Standards Act Exemption, Family and Medical Leave Act Hours of Service via U.S. Department of Labor
The AI Deregulation Illusion: Why CIOs Face More Rules, Not Fewer via CIO.com
DOL Proposes New Job Search Standard for Unemployment Benefits via SHRM
Key Congressional Benefits Panels Could Soon Favor National Health Plan Oversight via BenefitsPRO
Feds Seek Overhaul of Permanent Immigrant Worker Regulations via HR Dive
IBM Tells Sponsored Consulting Staff to Leave the US or Quit by Year-End After Ending Visa Support via IBTimes UK
SEC Aims to Pare Back Executive Comp Disclosure Rules via HR Dive
House Passes Bill Enabling 403(b) Plans to Invest Using Collective Investment Trusts via PlanSponsor
Have a great rest of your week!


